Showing posts with label blog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label blog. Show all posts

Monday, May 2, 2016

In the moment

Recently I’ve noticed a pattern in my creative pursuits. If I don’t do an idea as soon as I get it, it’s likely I won’t go through with it. I tend to get excited about an idea when I have it, and that’s the prime time to do it. Many times I do go through with it, and that’s awesome! But other times I’ll just write it down and hope to come back to it later. But as I said, I find that I tend to not follow through on the ideas I don’t implement immediately (or if I do follow through with them, it’s more difficult to be as passionate or excited about them as I was when I conceived the idea). 

I’ve seen this play out mostly with Conjecture. I’ll have ideas about videos I want to make or concepts I’m excited about and write them down. Many of these I’ll try to do quickly, but that definitely doesn’t happen with all of them. In fact, now that I think about it I have often been “waiting” to do a specific video I had wanted to do for a while. This is usually something I’ve put off for a while that I genuinely do want to create. But I instead wind up doing a video on some other topic that inspired me much more recently. I used to feel kind of guilty about this, but now thinking about it through this context I don’t feel as bad: it’s easier to pursue an idea in the moment than one I was excited about a while ago.


So now that I’ve realized this, I’m trying to research/film/make/do things as soon as possible after I get the idea. That’s why I’m writing this now: it’s not exactly a long or impressive blog post, but I wanted to get my thoughts out there. Hopefully I’ll be able to follow through on this idea, haha.

Monday, April 11, 2016

Reading a Book

This weekend I went on a retreat with my a cappella group, NOTA. It was a lot of fun and we spent most of our time talking and hanging out with each other. However about 2 or 3 times I wanted to excuse myself from the group to read a book I liked, one that I wanted to get back to reading. The first time I said this to the group they said something like, “Why did you bring that here? You’re with all of us!” This was asked out of pure curiosity with perhaps a hint of mild judgment. But around the second or third time I wanted to excuse myself to read, the message took a different tone: “Seriously, why are you doing that?? You can do that anytime!” These replies, I felt, were more intended to guilt me away from reading and back into spending time with them.

So I get that I could read a book anytime and that everyone is here together, but reading is something I do to relax myself. I didn’t really say that at the time, but I figured most people viewed it that way. Also it’s not like I read so much that I dropped out of all the activities we did. I participated in pretty much everything we did, and only really read when I felt like there was a lull in what we were doing. I’d say the maximum amount of time I spent reading on this day-and-a-half trip was one hour.


…Do these attitudes towards me reading seem kind of harsh? Yeah? If you think so, you’re not alone. Maybe I can offer an explanation: I wasn’t ever actually reading, and I never said I was going to go read. I said I was going to play video games.


Ah, now it makes sense—I didn’t get this treatment because I wanted to read, it was because I wanted to play video games! But...everything I said otherwise was true. For me, video games offer a kind of relaxing solace others find in reading. I want to spend time with my friends, and I did that for the vast majority of the weekend. But sometimes I just want to do the things that relax me and make me feel happy, which is often playing video games.

We have this stigma about video games that prevents many of us from seeing them as anything beyond some dumb thing that wastes our time. I see them in the same light as reading for fun, they’re experiences that engage your mind in a gripping and exciting way. I’d actually argue in many cases video games can provide more than books, like forcing your brain to think how to act in novel situations, or allowing you to experience deeply interactive scenarios not often present in books.*

I don’t want to made to feel bad about doing something I love, especially when it’s not seriously impacting my life or anyone else’s in a negative way. I just want to help others understand why this stigmatized, child’s activity might actually be more than meets the eye

<3


~~~~Footnote~~~~
*This isn’t to say that video games are more fun or better for you overall than reading is (I read a lot, by the way). Video games and books each have their strengths. Books often make me think about my worldviews and expose me to ideas I’d never before considered. Video games don’t do that very often. But video games do let me share an immediate experience with someone in a visceral way I don’t find from books. They also act as a very specific test: “how good can you be at doing XYZ?” Honestly having written this out I don’t even see why we need to compare the benefits they bring—do whichever brings you more enjoyment!

Sunday, March 27, 2016

Models of Creativity Applied to Andy Weir's "The Martian"

I’ve recently been reading books and articles about creative success and I started thinking about two principles of creativity I’ve heard reiterated frequently: (1) creators are often bad at predicting which of their works will be the most successful, and (2) they usually have lots of works that aren’t as widely acclaimed before their first big hit. 

After I started generalizing these rules in my head I naturally began to think of outliers to prove them and myself wrong. I thought of Andy Weir’s “The Martian,” his debut novel which not only became a motion-picture featuring Matt Damon, but also earned him recognition and privileges from important people at NASA. This was his first novel, and he had experienced tremendous success, so here was the outlier to these rules. Or so I thought.

As I thought about the situation more, I realized it wasn’t too derivative from what I had said earlier. The first criteria checks out perfectly: Weir didn’t expect at all for the book to become the massive success it did. The second one seems difficult to counter, because this was his first novel. But it certainly wasn’t his first bit of writing. Weir kept a blog with an active reader base for a while before he began work on the novel. And he actually published his novel on his blog, chapter by chapter. He received feedback from his readers and made several big changes to the book based on his readers’ feedback. Even though the novel was perhaps his first formal and complete work, he had written many other things before it.

It doesn’t fit the model to a T, but a fit exists. I also will go back later and cite these sources…I’m just tired right now.


THERE YOU GO.

Tuesday, March 15, 2016

My Voice

I’m glad we had until Wednesday to write this blog because while I’ve been able to process some parts of our trip well, other parts are still coming in. Anyway, let’s begin.

One of the biggest moments of the trip happened right off the bat for me, at the Atlanta Civil and Human Rights Museum. There was a clip in an exhibit showing this…well, why don’t you just watch it below:



Every time I’ve recounted this story to someone I’ve cried. It just…I feel like I can’t adequately explain in words how this affected me. I think my writing is good, but I find it hard to convey the tones and emotions I was feeling at the time. And that’s why below I’ve attached an audio file that I recorded during the trip, a file where I spoke my mind about everything I had heard. I created this at 10:30 at night after having done MLK’s march on Washington by myself (after having done it with the group).

Like I said in the opening paragraph, I do still have to process everything I’ve heard. I have this desire to put it into a cohesive narrative, whether or not that is even necessary. But for now this audio file will do. Enjoy~

https://soundcloud.com/mattmignogna/sets/civil-rights-thoughts


Sunday, February 14, 2016

Thank You, Donald Trump

Based on the things Donald Trump has said (Mexicans are rapists, let’s ban Muslims, etc.), it’s very hard to argue he’s not racist—or at least that his rhetoric isn’t. In fact when people talk about Trump I tend to hear remarks like “oh my god our country is moving backwards.” However I want to argue that Donald Trump isn't moving us backward and in fact is helping us. That seems like a ridiculous thing to say, so let me explain:

While Donald Trump is the one saying these extreme things, one man alone saying extreme things is not important. But when lots of people start to agree with him and support him, that’s when things become interesting. And yes while there are some followers who don’t believe Trump will enact his ideas and follow him more for his audacity and status as an outsider, I believe there are just as many (if not more) who genuinely believe in his ideas. Just take a look at this clip from CNN after Trump said he wanted to rid the US of Muslims.

I don’t think Trump is actually influencing anyone’s views. I think his supporters have always believed what Trump is saying, but we’re just seeing it now. These people had these views the entire time but now that there’s a high-profile public figure talking about it fearlessly, they feel safer themselves to come out with their views. Seriously, watch the CNN clip again and look at the guy interviewed at 1:10. The reporter presses him to say whether or not he agrees with Trump’s Muslims-removal plan and after looking over both his shoulders cautiously, he says yes. You can feel that he’s uncomfortable saying this because he knows it’s not a popular position. And while I don’t agree with the idea, I totally understand why he’d be scared to say something like this.

And this is why Trump is actually really important and helpful: he is empowering people to say what they believe. This shows everyone else what we’re actually dealing with. We will never be able to change peoples ideas if we don’t really know what they are. I mean, think back to the guy from the CNN clip. How could we possibly hold a meaningful conversation and attempt to understand why he feels the way he does if we never even knew how he really felt.

Here’s the bottom line: I agree with almost nothing that Trump says. But he has proved to us that we have a lot more work to do than we thought. And for that we owe him thanks.

Friday, February 12, 2016

So Good They Can't Ignore You

This is a summary of the main points in Cal Newport's book So Good They Can't Ignore You.

.....

Summary
  1. "Follow your passion" is bad career advice. Many people don't have pre-existing passions and their path to finding work they loved was complicated.
  2. Great work is rare and valuable so you, in return, need something rare and valuable to offer in return: career capital. This is basically high proficiency in something useful. You have to be So Good They Can't Ignore You (Steve Martin quote and the book's title). 
    • To develop yourself to the point of being so good you can't be ignored, you need deliberate practice. This is practice where you intentionally force yourself to practice increasingly difficult tasks because overcoming/learning them will make you better. This part sucks, but it's how you develop skills instead of plateauing like most of us do. 
    • It's easy to see this applied to athletes and musicians, but we don't tend to hold this mindset for everyone else. That is a big mistake.
  3. Control over what you do and how you do it is super important. Cal calls control the "Dream-Job Elixir." This could mean leaving your job and starting a similar but more independent role or many other things. There are two traps to fall into with control, however. 
    • The First Control Trap: it's dangerous to try and gain more control (leave you work, do something radical) if you don't have enough career capital to back it up.
    • The Second Control Trap: once you have a lot of career capital, employers won't want to lose you and will fight to keep you on your traditional path.
    • Use the Law of Financial Viability (do you have clear evidence that people are willing to pay you for your capital) to discern how much career capital you have and which control area you may be in.
  4. To build work you love you cash in career capital for valuable traits like control and mission, a bigger reason or calling for your work.  
    • The best ideas for mission are found at the adjacent possible (where you're at the cutting edge of your field and so you can understand things about your field that most others can't). 
    • Once you have a mission you have to make it succeed, so generate small steps that produce feedback. Cal calls these little bets. 
    • Finally, adopt the mindset of a marketer to make your work known. This is the Law of Remarkability: it must (1) literally compel people to remark about it, and (2) launched in a venue conducive to sharing and remarking.
One last thing I should mention: Cal argues that for most jobs it doesn't matter what you're doing specifically because you can become good at it and ultimately love doing it. However he does list three job attributes that would each prevent workers from developing following Cal's ideas.

  1. Few opportunities to distinguish yourself by developing rare and valuable skills
  2. Job focuses on something you believe is useless or harmful to the world
  3. Job forces you to work with people you dislike

Thoughts
  1. If many people don't have pre-existing passions, that means they were developed from...something. So could we potentially alter our existing passions and create new ones with some cognitive framing? I think the answer is yes. Also, we haven't experienced everything we ultimately will, so the scale we use to judge how much we like something could change drastically as we find out new awesome things we didn't know existed. 
    • however, I think it's a little quick to throw out the idea of passion altogether. Obviously as people find work they love they become passionate about it, and passion also seems to describe mission. So perhaps it'd be more beneficial to think about passion after you have career capital and control rather than before or never.
  2. This part I totally agree with, especially deliberate practice. It's humbling to think about how many skills of mine alone have plateaued: piano, beatboxing, singing, smash, YouTube (maybe?), and I'm sure many other that aren't coming to mind. Deliberate practice is just how you get better and we often don't do it because it's difficult...I want to focus a lot on this in my personal life, and that will be discussed more later on in this post. 
  3. Control, autonomy, has come up in literature time and time again as being important to people. While reading this I tended to think of freelance-type work as one of few paths with more control, but more control could simply mean a different role in one's organization. 
    • As for the second control trap, I think to the movie Get Smart with Steve Carrel. Because Steve is the company's best analyst, he's turned down for a promotion because they feel like they can't afford to lose him in his job. If Steve had read this book, he would have known that he had a lot of leverage at that point.
  4. This section really loses me. I think Cal is stretching his examples to fit this category. One guy for instance is an archaeology grad who loves communicating and eventually gets a show on the discovery channel. I don't know if he needed a mission for that, he was just good at communicating and happened to come across the right people and loved doing what he did. The "little bets" were a side-result of his fervor. I think gaining enough capital to experience the adjacent possible is really important, though I don't think you need to be in the AP to experience a passion or mission. I think experiencing the AP is more reflctive of how much career capital you have rather than connected to mission. Now I do think the law of remarkability is actually quite legitimate, but I feel like it accounts more for people recognizing you for your career capital, not building a mission. 

Plans Moving Forward 

[I'll probably come back and edit this section later, just posting initial thoughts here right now]

The biggest things I took from this book are (1) that it's absolutely worthwhile to get very good at things and (2) we achieve a high level of skill only through deliberate practice. With that in mind, I want to take a more intentional approach towards completing the tasks and developing the skills I want. Specifically, applying for internships and increasing my proficiency in graphic design, coding and YouTube.

I think I should put these tasks to a schedule, doing each on certain days so I can focus exclusively on one per day. Until I apply for a fair amount of internships the internships will carry a disproportionate amount of weight. Here's the schedule:

Minimum 30 min per day on each subject:
M–Internship Application
T–YouTube
W–Internship Application
R–Photoshop Tutorial
F–Coding
Weekend–YouTube

For the Internships, I will mostly just be applying to places I've found and looking up potential opportunities. Not much deliberate practice as I see it, more of just completing a task.

For photoshop and coding I'm still learning the basics, so I'll be continuing tutorials online. That qualifies as deliberate practice because I'm learning new things that will naturally be difficult and different.

For Youtube, I had to spend more time thinking of how I can deliberately practice being "better" at what I'm doing there. For that purpose I'm going to make a list of traits I think described good YT-ers. [I'm almost finished but I have to post this at 8, sooooo I'll be coming back to it later]

  1. Engaging speaker, passionate about topic


YouTube section:
I think I need to differentiate first whether I want to just improve my skill or also try intentionally to grow (because while connected, those are two different things). I'll talk about just improving for now.

Here's a short list of the qualities I think make YouTubers great
-they have fun with their own style.




 layout a schedule and plan to help me work on the skills I want to develop. At this moment in time, those are coding, photoshop, getting an internship (not a skill, but whatevs) and YouTube. importantly, (2) that deliberate practice is critical to becoming better at what you do.

  1. I'm coming back to this.
What are the things that, right now, I want to be better at. 
photoshop, coding, youtube. 

going ham on YouTube? and i guess internship...resume.


.....
Mid-way through writing this I came across this post by my friend Serena. I had read it before and bookmarked it, and now because of its title I read it again. http://serenafulton.com/2015/05/05/why-following-your-passion-is-bad-career-advice/

Tuesday, February 9, 2016

Generalizing Psych Activities

In my multi-cultural psychology class we did this activity: thumb-wrestle for 1 minute and each time a partner pins the other, they get .2 extra credit points. As soon as we were told this and paired up, I said to my partner, "this makes me feel awkward, let’s do whatever and say we each won twice.” She agreed.

Our thumb-wrestling was really more pleasant conversation than anything else—mostly about how my thumbs relative to hers were enormous and how the activity therefore wasn't fair. I did wind up winning both of the two wrestles we did. Time was up and the teacher started to say what I (and probably you) had expected all along.

This activity wasn’t about the winner or loser, it was about how we would engage in the activity, specifically whether we had more collectivistic (cooperative, group-oriented) or individualistic (competitive, individual-oriented) tendencies. It was meant to elicit behavior like me proposing we split the victories regardless of the outcome. As the teacher was explaining this, my partner said she’d write down that I’d won 3 wrestles and she’d won 1. 

This activity was...interesting. My teacher said it was to see whether we were more collectivistic or individualistic but I strongly contest the fact that an exercise like this provides much real insight into our generalized behavior. There are soooo many others factors coming into play. 

Yes, I said let’s split the points. No, that doesn’t necessarily make me a collectivistic person. I said what I did because I personally don’t value .6 points of extra credit so much that I’d be competitive to an off-putting extent. In my opinion the social perception of being a “tryhard” strongly trumps the insignificant amount of extra credit available. 

So whether I’m an individualistic person or not (I am), this activity doesn’t reflect my true beliefs because there are other social factors that act on the situation with greater strength than the extra credit incentive did. From a brief glance around the room, it seemed like most if not all students had made some sort of “collectivist compromise” like myself, though we have no way of really knowing whether or not this collectivism applies to any other aspects of our lives. 

So this collectivism activity, while it may shed light on some specific situational attitudes, cannot be generalized because there are too many other factors at play. I’m guessing my teacher knows this, but it still bothered me enough that I wanted to write about it, haha. 


A couple of other things I noticed:

  • My partner wrote down 3-1 instead of the actual score, 2-0. She probably felt that even though I said I was totally fine splitting the total that she should be fair. 
  • We could have kept the orginal score because I still had two more than her. But 2-0 is significantly different from 3-1 because with the latter she also earns points. 
  • Lastly, while I did say we should make it even, I didn’t specifically lose intentionally to make our scores actually even. I was just going to do the thumb-wrestling, disregard the ultimate score, and say we were even. After I won two I could have (very obviously) let myself lose so we both actually won and lost twice. I wonder if other people did this. Does it say anything about me? Probably, but I don’t know exactly what. Let me know your thoughts below :) 

Monday, February 1, 2016

The Longest Ever Study on Happiness

This TED Talk discusses the longest ever study on happiness. It followed 724 men from their childhood to their 90s, and it has spanned generations of researchers. These men were originally students from either Harvard or Boston’s worst suburbs. I summarized the main points of the talk below:

  1. Social connections are really good for us. Loneliness kills. People connected to families, communities are happier, healthier, live longer. More isolated people are less happy, less healthy, brain functioning declines, they live shorter lives. (1/5 Americans are lonely)
  2. It’s not just the number of friends or being in a relationship that makes you happy, but the quality of those relationships. Living in warm relationships is good, protective. Living in bad relationships is worse than a divorce. Biggest predictor of health at 80 had nothing to do with cholesterol or physical ailments: people who were most satisfied in relationships at 50 were healthiest at 80 (when they had more physical pain, their moods were still happy). But for people in unhealthy relationships, the emotional pain magnified the physical pain.
  3. Being in securely attached relationship to another person keeps your memory sharper longer.

As we can see, the ultimate takeaway is that good relationships keep us happier and healthier. Nothing about fame or wealth correlates that strongly.* The speaker mentions in the beginning that over 80% of millenials have the goal to get rich, and 50% want to become famous. I don’t know if it’s only millenials who have these unrealistic life aspirations, but watching this TED talk could help a lot of them realize that perhaps that goal isn’t the best one.




*Other researchers have found similar things, that while money may correlate up to a degree, it isn’t as big as we think (https://www.ted.com/talks/daniel_kahneman_the_riddle_of_experience_vs_memory?language=en).

Friday, January 8, 2016

i still have things to say

Yesterday I watched a video from Jake Roper after he’d learned he had Sarcoma, a type of cancer. He talked about how his biggest fear isn’t dying, but not being able to make and do and be all the things he wants to. I never thought about death in that particular light, but I realized I share Jake’s fear exactly. I’m worried that, as Jake says, “I'll leave this world at some point with not enough of me left in it.” Whether it’s through YouTube or photoshop or Live Hangouts, or blogs, I have this desire to create things. So I created something last night: a video that was uploaded today. 

I said basically all of those things but in a less digestible way (I recorded the video in the spur of the moment and my thoughts weren’t yet coherently collected). But now that they are I can say them with more clarity: I will be putting out more content because I want to get my ideas out there. 

If I wanted to publish more videos similar to those I do now, I think I’d work myself to death. Because that doesn’t sound fun, I’m instead adding a certain type of video in addition to the videos I normally put out. These videos will differ in two noticeable ways.
  1. They’ll have a less tightly-edited style, meaning they’ll be similar to vloggers and the video I just posted.
  2. Instead of doing complex analyses of publications and/or science, they’ll be more focused on thoughts and conjecture (haha very funny). For example, is a narrator accountable for the information they read?


I’ve posted these ideas for a while on this blog, but I might as well do it on YouTube, too. I think that’s the best way to get all of this out there :)

Sunday, December 20, 2015

Wikipedia Calculations

This is a little write-up explaining some statistics and calculations I did for my most recent video, “Can You Read All of Wikipedia?” While the statistics from the video are all approximately correct (as I mentioned), they should have been a little more accurate. I want to explain why.

Let's begin with this Wikipedia article showing Wikipedia's word count. 


Two things should stand out: 

  1. The word count here is 2.95 billion, not 2.9275 billion like I claimed, and...
  2. After the word count the brackets literally say “not in citation given”
These two are both related. It was September 1st* when I last checked this page and finalized my calculations. Back then, it said that there were 2.9275 billion words and it didn’t have that bracket saying that number wasn’t in the citation. I tried to look through the edits to find this number but I couldn’t. I really remember seeing that number there (because where else would I have gotten it?) but it's seeming more and more like I pulled it out of thin air.ª

ANYWAY the point is that even if that number had been there, I didn’t verify it by checking the source. As someone who attempts to research material with academic curiosity and legitimacy, this is embarrassingly irresponsible. I will say that with virtually every other topic I’ve ever done through YT, I did verify the source, but for this one I chose not to. Maybe I trusted the source because it was Wikipedia writing about itself, or maybe because I thought this would be a short video and it wouldn’t be a big deal. Either way, I should have checked the source and noticed that both 2.9275 and 2.95 billion aren’t supported by the available data. 

The actual source links to the English Wikipedia's statistics page. Here do find a word count here...but it’s most recent count comes from January 2010. 


Since the total word count hasn't been updated after 2010, we really have no way of definitively knowing from this source what the current word count is. Yet I think I have a guess as to where the contributor got 2.95 billion. If you divide Jan 2010’s 1.798 billion by 3.1 million, the Jan. 2010 article count, then you get an average of 580 words-per-article. Now if we assume that that WpA doesn’t change over the years, then multiplying it with the current article amount of 5.1 million would give us a current word count of 2.9 billion. Not exactly 2.95 billion—we’d need an average of 590 WpA for that—but close enough that I feel comfortable saying we’re in the right ballpark.

Speaking of the 590 WpA count, I actually made my first ever Wikipedia edit to point this out. You can see me explaining what I did and also asking what methodology the previous contributor used to arrive at their conclusions. 


So we’ve worked out the number of total words. The other stat I mentioned is that Wikipedia was adding 440,000 words daily to the site. Is this number of words accurate?

Probably not, because I used the exact same methodology as before (checked it Sept. 1st, didn’t check source, used a random wiki page). So if we’re working with the 2010 WpA count, multiplying that by August’s° new article count gives us an average of 492,420 words added daily. Again, not exactly the same, but close enough that I’m okay saying my original data was approximately correct.

Looking back, I’m not sure if it would have been smarter to use 2010 numbers. Obviously they’re more accurate, but Wikipedia’s clearly grown so much since then that while the 2010 data may be more numerically accurate, it might actually be a less accurate representation of Wikipedia. 

. . . . .

I made this post detailing how a couple numbers I used were off by a certain degree. But this degree turned out to be relatively small…why did I write this, publicly announcing my (seemingly) small mistake? 

I value academic transparency and sources. I think if you’re involved in education (i.e. professing to know something others don’t) it’s your responsibility to not mislead others and publicly provide access to the information which informed you. I believe learners have a right to know where knowledge came from so they may examine it for themselves. If I make mistakes I want to explain why it happened and make sure people have access to the correct information.

However I’m okay with making these mistakes because I’m trying a lot of new things. Almost all of my videos up to this point have been simply reciting information I’ve learned. But my last two videos** haven’t been reciting information—they’ve been creating new information from scratch. No source told me how to convert video to words or to measure humans’ ability to read Wikipedia. That was my math, my thought process, my original work. 

So I’m okay with making these types of mistakes because (1) I learn from them, and (2) it means I’m trying more complex things I haven’t done before. I like that :)


~~~Footnote~~~
ªIf you’d like to look for it please be my guest :) https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Size_in_volumes&action=history

*I did think I would publish this video sooner than I did (more than three months after the research), but ultimately I should have done recalculations to check and see if the stats changed much. They didn’t change much, but as I’ve said the point of this post is to highlight my exact methodology as well as point out what I did irresponsibly and/or incorrectly. 

°Technically I’m not sure what month was used as the source for determining the article count, but I’m using August here since I collected my data on September 1st. 

**excluding the P4A one

Sunday, December 6, 2015

Interpreting the Law


I found this statement of academic integrity in a study guide for one my classes. I think this statement is intended to prevent one person from e-mailing the study guide to everyone in the class, but regardless the language is way too broad: “Distributing this information in any form…in any way…is a violation of academic integrity and the student code of conduct.” This means that if I physically give the unmodified study guide to a friend in the same class who had the ability to print it for himself, that’d be cheating. And that’s ridiculous.

This makes me think of two philosophies that exist for interpreting the laws: (1) that they should be followed to the letter with no exceptions or wiggle room and (2) that the laws are meant to represent general concepts and there can be extenuating circumstances where they shouldn’t apply. (Obviously I think the study guide falls into the second interpretation.) 

Now, there are good and bad componenents about each of these interpretations. For (1), it is very clear and obvious what constitutes the law, which I think makes applying and understanding it easier. The bad thing is that it might penalize people who share an unmodified study guide even though his friend had the ability to print it for himself. For (2), the good is that it wouldn’t penalize that person, but the bad is that it can be time-consuming to decide things on a case-by-case basis and it could also be difficult to “draw the line” in terms of where the extenuating circumstances lie. Still I lean towards the second one because laws are written without the full understanding of how they might play out in the real world. If my teacher saw me hand a printed study guide to a friend, I doubt she’d even think of it as cheating.


I thought about all of this because my friend actually e-mailed me a study guide she filled out and shared it with me. I didn’t think twice of this until I realized that this was technically cheating. But it doesn’t feel like it…I mean, we could have just as easily met up in-person and read our thoughts and research for each question. If we were called into the office of student academic integrity, I’d make a good case for us.

Sunday, November 22, 2015

Facing the Voice: Thoughts on Meeting Bill Nye



On Wednesday night I met Bill Nye the Science Guy!



Now you’d think that meeting a childhood idol and hugely popular science educator would leave me like this


But it actually left me more like this


Meeting celebrities in-person can be a dangerous game. Obviously it’s super cool to talk with the people who fascinate you, but you also run a big risk: knowing what they’re really like. 

Yes, we’d all like to think there’s no way this person whom we’ve grown up watching could be anything other than their awesome, on-screen persona. But notice that term, persona. A persona is a role played by an actor, and I used that word for a specific reason. In real life, celebrities might be nothing like their persona. 



This can’t be news to anyone—we’ve all heard stories about this. Even so, it didn't cross my mind when I got tickets (and backstage passes!) to see Bill Nye at Penn State.


The lecture was great and showed me every reason to love this guy: he’s funny, intelligent, fascinating, and an excellent communicator. But backstage was a slightly different story. 

It started off with a procession line leading everyone to Bill for a picture. This came off as celebrity worship and seemed a little strange, but I figured we’d see the more human side of him after it ended so I didn’t mind. 

Instead of a phone, I went up to him with my camera to ask if he’d say something for Conjecture (“brother, I’ll see you on weekday”). As I was describing it, he cut me off and said “you can’t do this, what if everyone wanted to record a video? Just take a picture” I apologized and took out my phone, but he told me I wasn’t ready and sent me behind someone in line. 

Of course I shouldn’t judge him too much from my one interaction…but he was like this with everyone, coldly telling people to hurry up with their pictures and get out of line as soon as they were done. Attempts at polite small talk were essentially met with “come on, you can’t do this now.” 

I'd already had a sour taste in my mouth from observing all this, but he did say that there’d be time for more talking and stuff after the picture line. So I waited to see the real Bill Nye.

Unfortunately, nothing really changed. After the pictures everyone did gather around him to interact in a more intimate way, but it instead devolved into a semi-formal Q&A. Genuine exchanges were infrequent and it ultimately still felt like celebrity worship. I expected to be the audience during the lecture, not while I was backstage too.


Now look, I get that everyone wanted a picture and that Bill's probably exhausted from talking to so many colleges and that he's kind of a big deal…but let’s compare this to another experience I’ve had.

At VidCon 2015 I met Vsauce’s Michael Stevens.



He was a fantastically nice dude. He was flooded with more people than Bill was and still took the time to hold genuine conversations with each individual that approached him. He only left because he was forced to, not because he wanted to. Needless to say, I was floored. In fact when I pulled this photo from my facebook, I saw a comment I wrote on July 25, 2015.

My facebook's in Italian :)

So yeah—we can make excuses for Bill Nye, but when I’m comparing his behavior to Michael Steven’s (who in many ways is more popular than Bill Nye), it just doesn't hold. 

All of this, meeting an idol and realizing they’re not as cool in person, makes me think of something I heard recently from CGP Grey on his podcast Hello Internet (skip to around 1:20:00). He was saying how seeing the faces of narrating voices like his own can actually ruin the experience for the audience. You wind up liking the narration in a such a unique way that seeing the real thing just doesn’t fit. And after seeing the real thing, the narration can no longer exist in your mind as a solely awesome creation, but rather the product of an ordinary person—it becomes less magical because you know the truth. If you don’t understand what I mean, maybe seeing real pictures of CGP Grey would help illustrate this (see footnote).

Meeting Bill Nye was like seeing that voice. Meeting any celebrity runs that risk. They might be just as you’d expect them, but they also might be something else. 

That night I traded the Bill Nye that existed in my head for this picture:



I want to trade it back.



~~~Footnotes~~~

RE: CGP Pictures...

CGP is okay with their dissemination, he mentioned that in the same Hello Internet Podcast after the section I wrote about. But remember what you just read! Think if you actually want to see what he looks like.

...

https://twitter.com/Alextigtig/status/533483252255031297
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C5MVXdg6nho
https://www.quora.com/What-does-CGP-Grey-look-like

Tuesday, November 17, 2015

Nice Guys and Relationships


So a while back someone I knew was very drunk and complaining to me. Of course, it was about a girl.

He liked this girl, she didn’t like him back…that was really it. BUT, he was going on and on and on about how he was so nice to her and she STILL didn't like him, that she doesn’t know what’s good for herself and maybe he just shouldn’t be nice at all anymore.

Now he was intoxicated, but I still couldn’t believe the words I was hearing. This is that "nice guys finish last" thing you hear in high school!

So I'm writing this post as a sort of response to that idea, and hopefully it can help anyone else, guy or gal, who is struggling with a similar situation.

~~Let's roll~~


Ok so first off, he’s thinking that basically because he’s so nice to her, she should fall for him. This seems to kind of make sense, until you consider some things:

  1. If niceness is all that makes someone attracted to someone else, then what's to stop someone from being nicer to this girl than you were? Based on your logic, this person would leave you instantly! But this doesn't happen, and that's because of the next thing...
  2. What attracts us to people is complicated, and not one-dimensional (i.e. it'll never be niceness alone). I mean, you could meet the nicest person in the world and not be attracted to them for many reasons! This is because we're also attracted to elements like ambition, personality, physical attractiveness, and sense of humour. Attraction is a complex combination of so many things that one alone would never sway a person (or, at least, it shouldn't). 
  3. Finally, you said “oh maybe I shouldn’t be nice in general anymore.” Okay, I’m assuming you meant you'd stop being nice just to people you're romantically interested in and not the general population, because the latter would be pretty stupid. So now that we have that established, here's the thing about this: yeah, niceness isn't the sole determinant for relationships, but girls like people who are nice!! Why would a girl, or anyone want to be with someone who’s mean?? I realize I’m not a girl here, but you gotta just trust me on this one. If a girl you like is attracted to someone who (in your view) isn't as nice as you are, it just means she sees another meaningful and attractive quality in him or her besides niceness.


So after I explained this to him, he proceeded to analogize his affection for this person: "What if you find the prettiest, most beautiful flower in the field, and you know it's the one for you and that there are no other flowers like her, but you can't have it. What then?"

There are a lot of reasons this analogy isn’t great.

  1. The idea that this is the most beautiful flower you’ll ever see becomes true when you decide you’re not going to explore the field anymore! If you just stand there admiring it, of course you’ll never find anything better! There’s a whole field of other beautiful flowers to find!
  2. But for argument’s sake, let’s say that this is indeed the most beautiful flower in the field, okay? Well to this I'll tell you that our personal standards of attraction change as we mature physically and emotionally. We will be attracted to different things at different points in our life, so even if that flower is (improbably) the most beautiful in the field, as you mature it probably won’t stay that way! And look, I know it’s really hard to get your mind around this and the last point when you're really into someone. I've been there. But I promise you that it always gets better with time. 


BUT OKAY let’s say it really is the most beautiful flower and you’re never going to change the way you feel (unlikely). There's still one huge problem with this analogy: women aren't flowers! You see, flowers are passive objects—they get admired and picked. But women (and people) are not!!! Except in extreme circumstances, people get their say in deciding who're they're attracted to. That’s just how relationships work.

Instead of looking at a relationship like admiring a flower, I think a better analogy is those hotel doors that connect rooms. If you’re attracted to someone, you can open your door and show it. But nothing will happen unless they open their door too, and just like in an actual hotel, they have the right not to open it.

Now when I was explaining all of this to him…well, most of it wasn’t getting through because he was really drunk. But I was also getting really angry that I even had to explain this stuff to him! But as I thought about it more, I realized something: he had never had any of this explained to him. Maybe it seems basic to you or me, but without hearing this concretely it can be a confusing and difficult concept to grasp. 

And when you view someone's actions through this lens, it becomes really difficult to stay angry with them. You just want to tell them "hey man, this is how the world works, and you’ll be happier and healthier when it sinks in." Unfortunately, I didn’t realize this in the moment and was getting incredibly frustrated with him…but yeah. Hopefully this helps some of you deal with this type of stuff. It would have been helpful to me too when I was younger.

Thursday, November 5, 2015

Why I have this blog

Hey there. So most of you who read this probably know I have a YouTube channel, Conjecture. There I've uploaded informational videos and vlogs. [The word "vlog" tends to have a simple or vapid connotation, though mine are more informational like the vlogbrothers' videos.]

Though I like my vlogging, I've decided that I want to direct less attention towards them on Conjecture. There are two main reasons for this:
  1. I think the informational videos are usually more fun to research and more rewarding than the vlogs, but more importantly...
  2. Because I generate vlog ideas faster than informational ones, they can take over my channel. 

Yeah, the vlogs would begin to outpace my informational videos. I would have 5 vlog ideas I'm thinking and writing about but all of my informational videos would be on hold.

So because I still like a lot of the ideas but want to do more informational videos, I'm posting all of my vlog ideas here—the only real difference is now they don't have video accompaniment. The really important or personally meaningful vlog ideas will still make their way to YouTube, but I'm expecting to post a lot fewer on YT.

I also realized this site can store all the other creative, non-YT things I do (like podcasts and typewriter musings). It's all an experiment, so let me know what you think! 

Friday, October 16, 2015

“_________ IS A STUPID IDIOT!”

Whenever I see articles with titles like these, I get pretty upset. Before the piece has even begun, the author’s language has communicated that they (1) lack the basic decency required to have productive discussions, and (2) are probably too biased to understand the other side, if they’re even able to. 
Essentially, these articles serve mainly to ignite the passions behind the like-minded people who routinely read them. When our nation is the most polarized it has been in 20 years, what we need are avenues for discussion and debate that promote understanding rather than hoisting up a winning individual or ideology. 
Do you know one of the best ways to make someone close off their willingness to consider competing ideas? Insult them or someone they support. And not only is it a bad strategy for discussion, it’s just rude. I am liberal-leaning, yes, but the only reason I would ever flat-out dismiss someone is not if their ideology differs, but if they’re being a jerk and not even attempting to understand a different point of view. I simply don’t want to surround myself with people like that.
I don’t exactly know how we can begin to change this volatile climate, so I will instead leave you with a quote that is becoming more accurate every day:
To understand the workings of American politics, you have to understand this fundamental law: Conservatives think liberals are stupid. Liberals think conservatives are evil. — Charles Krauthammer

Friday, October 9, 2015

con·jec·ture | kənˈjekCHər

A while ago I was Googling "Conjecture" to see where my YouTube channel would come up in the results. The first thing anyone sees when Googling it is this:



Seeing that was…fun. I guess I knew the meaning of the word before I created my channel, but I had always interpreted conjecture as more of an educated guess, almost like a hypothesis. 

Later on, @Blackmak5 tweeted this photo at me:



A general conclusion based on facts and results? That’s way better than what Google said. But now I had these two pretty different meaning of conjecture, so I wanted to do some digging and find out what this word really means. 

Let’s start off with the etymological origins.



Here we see that the word “conjecture” comes originally from the combination of the Latin “con” (together) and “jacere” (to throw). So the word’s original verb form, conicere, literally meant “to throw together,” referring specifically to thoughts. The word's noun form, conjetura, represented the product of thrown-together thoughts: a conclusion. 

So the modern word “conjecture" should be what you get when you piece results or thoughts together. That’s how I had interpreted it, and it's the definition @Blackmak5 found in his math textbook. But that sounds very different from the current definition Google provides, "an opinion or conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information." Somewhere along the line an additional connotation was added to the definition, that the information used to form it is inherently incomplete. That connotation may have been the Old French influence, or simply a result of the way language changes. I don’t know 


But wait, the definition @Blackmak5 found was from a math textbook…so is there a mathematical definition for “conjecture” different from Google’s general definition?


Let's take a look at Wikipedia's definition of mathematical conjecture:



"In mathematics, a conjecture is a conclusion or proposition based on incomplete information, but for which no proof has been found.” That doesn’t really bode well, either. But it goes on to say that conjectures "have shaped much of mathematical history as new areas of mathematics are developed in order to solve them.” 

So while the layman’s definition has "conjecture" as a conclusion formed by throwing together a bunch of incomplete information, mathematics interprets conjecture more like an idea that encourages the development of new science. That is the definition I want to get behind. 



Or, you know, I could just change my channel name to conjecturevlog since that’s my channel twitter and subreddit, and it’d make everything more unique, searchable and consistent. 

We’ll see. 

Friday, September 25, 2015

I Don't Like Personality Tests

In one of my classes we talked about personality tests and other related measures used for interviews. The class was boring, but the ideas we were talking about weren’t, so I wrote a lot of this post in that class (what a good example this sets). 

A lot of personality tests feature polarizing question—they’ll ask, “If you have the option of going to a party or reading a book, what would you do?” My answer for this would almost always be “it depends.” What’s the book? Am I 30 pages from being finished? Is anyone I know at the party? Is this a going-away party for my best friend? There are so many variables that play into a simple question like this, yet you’re supposed to choose either book or party, and then be judged as an introvert or extrovert off of that. Obviously, there are other questions on the exam meant to support the overall test’s findings, but so many of these questions only you to respond in this dichotomous manner. 

What I’ve found about regarding my personal levels of extroversion and introversion is that I display the defining qualities of both introverts and extroverts pretty frequently. This means I (along with many others) am considered an ambivert. What really determines how I’ll act is my mood and situation. Am I really happy that day? I’ll be more extraverted. Tired or sad? I’ll be introverted. Have I been really active and talked with a lot of people that day? I’ll carry over that energy, and continue to do that. Have I been keeping to myself that day? I’ll probably stick to that. And though most people may lean more to one side than I do, there really is no person that’s purely extraverted or purely introverted.

The ultimate point I’m trying to make here is that we as humans are complex, and though I think personality tests have promise, at this point they don’t do a great job of describing us. Here’s another example:

There’s this concept known as Locus of Control. It’s the idea that you are in control of your life, that what happens to you in life is the result of your work and actions, etc. There’s a personality test that measures LoC, and it tries to predict concepts like your level of self-efficacy and how much control you perceive yourself to have over your life. They ask questions like what happens to me is the result of my own actions and I am where I am today because of my actions. To me, these polarized questions just don’t include the complexities of real human lives. For example, I totally believe that a lot of what happens to you is the result of your own actions, but a lot of people face prejudice and discrimination that could legitimately prevent them from getting as far as they can go. I also think that I played a large role in getting my life to this point, but I would be mad to say I didn’t get help from my parents, or upper-middle class upbringing, or other experiences. 

So when I see these types of questions, I move the tool to say I agree around 50–70%. The test comes back and tells me I have moderate Locus of Control, that I feel I control some aspects of my life, but not others. From this result, employers (and perhaps the test-taker) infer that I can’t control those other things because I don’t believe in my own ability to affect change, and not because there are just so many things that others or I cannot control. And that’s where I disagree. I have high self-efficacy, high regard for my own abilities, but I also recognize that everything I’ve accomplished isn’t solely due to me, and that others may be more disadvantaged than I am. Just another example of how personality tests don’t do a great job of capturing the complexity of human attributes. 

I should say: though I’ve been railing against personality tests for not being able to capture the entire human experience, that is (1) incredibly difficult for any test to do, and (2) not necessarily the goal of personality tests. These tests are meant to provide merely a glimpse into someone’s life—there are a lot of other ways people get to know the real you, like, oh shoot what’s it called...conversing. So in a way, perhaps I’m getting bent out of shape for nothing: I’m getting frustrated because these tests aren’t serving the purpose they aren’t created to. 

BUT EVEN SO these tests could do a better job of capturing the complexity that is humanity. How can something as complex as personality be boiled down to A or B? It’s just annoying to be told that I’m either a circle or a square when I’m really a star. 

~~~Extra~~~
Here’s another paragraph I didn’t incorporate into the body

Another thing I’d like to note about personality tests is that if you know what an employer is searching for, it’s easy to answer questions in a way that makes you look very favorable. For example, if you’re taking an Five Factor Model test (“The Big Five,” or “OCEAN,” as some may know it) and you know that conscientious is correlated well across job performance, and neuroticism poorly, then you answer questions in a way that make you seem reliable, trustworthy, and emotionally stable. "Of course my room is always clean!” “Of course I’m not easily upset!" And if you want a promotion, just make sure to answer the questions about extraversion in a manner that paints as, well, extraverted. These correlations are not too hard to look into, and anyone with basic knowledge of this can manipulate their answers in a way that makes them appear more desirable than they may really be. Of course, it will be quickly apparent when doing the job what your real personality is like, but you don’t want to hire someone only to fire them immediately after. 

~~~Further Resources~~~

Popular Personality Tests (just google them)
FFM—Five Factor Model
MBTI—Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
LoC—Locus of Control


Stuff on extraversion/introversion/ambiversion came from Susan Cain’s book, Quiet.

Saturday, September 12, 2015

Breast Cancer Slacktivism

Last week I noticed my friend had posted a weird status on facebook. I had seen someone else post it, so I assumed they had clicked on some bad site and it was auto-posting to their status without their knowledge. I commented and said that. I got this message in response: 




Ok, how in any way does this raise awareness for breast cancer??? It doesn’t! The status that you’re supposed to post doesn’t mention breast cancer, and the message you receive if you comment on it doesn’t say anything other than “continue the game for breast cancer awareness.” 

This is slacktivism at it’s finest, and I hesitate to use that word. Even while people denounced #BringBackOurGirls as slacktivism for not producing any tangible results, it did raise actual awareness for the issue—people knew what was happening. This status doesn't even attempt to explain what is happening until you "fall victim" to it by commenting or liking it. 

The ALS Ice Bucket Challenge also faced allegations of slacktivism, yet it is anything but. It encouraged a lot of people to actually learn about ALS. It raised $115 million in 6 weeks. And it may have helped scientists find a legitimate breakthrough in not just ALS but a host of other diseases. These nice things happened because (1) it was fun to watch celebrities dumping buckets of water on their heads, and (2) it said “do this ridiculous thing OR DONATE MONEY.” That last part is crucial. 

Back to the breast cancer status. It doesn’t encourage people to donate. It doesn’t encourage people to learn about the disease. It doesn't even raise awareness, which is the least it could do. It doesn’t do anything helpful. What it DOES do is guilt people into reposting it, for fear of being anti-fun or anti-breast cancer. And that’s why responses like this usually tend to take people back:




If you take “for breast cancer awareness” out of the original facebook post, it’s just a social media game. And there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that! It’s social media, have fun with it. But don’t claim it supports breast cancer when it really doesn’t. 

Here’s a status that actually raises awareness for Breast Cancer:





Actually, the only way I think this status may raise awareness of breast cancer is that it gets a small percentage of people angry enough that they make their own post about how it raises awareness. I guess that's technically true, but it doesn't sit right with me. 


Feel free to disagree (and explain why)!

Friday, August 28, 2015

Want the Truth? Dig Deep.



I’ve recently been thinking about how difficult it can be to uncover the truth. Let me explain...



I’m writing a script for a YouTube video on electric cars. Specifically, “Are Electric Cars ACTUALLY Better for the Environment?” The totally uninformed answer is “uh, YA, we’re not burning fossil fuels!” The slightly-more-informed, yet still-not-complete answer is “well, no, because the electricity has to be generated somehow, and that’ll probably be with coal donchaknow?” 

The answer to this question (if we ever arrive at at truly definitive one) is not easy to come by because there are so many articles  and studies and professors and programs saying totally different things. Look at the results we get when we google search this question in two different ways:










Only one of the top 4 results articles is the same and the other three seem at least partially framed for the searcher. Can we trust those? And can we necessarily trust the Washington Examiner article just because it appeared in both?



HOW TO FIND THE TRUTH: You have to dig, and you’ll start by opening many (if not all) of these articles. If they cite no specific research or statistics (which some actually do), you can probably throw it out. If they cite research, look up the paper. Read the “methods” section. Contact the authors if you’re still confused. This is how you start obtaining what might be the closest thing to objective “truth” we’ll find. Sometimes this can be simple, and just one or two sites will explain away the misconceptions. But sometimes it goes deeper, deeper to the point where I start wondering how two legitimate, respectable parties have arrived at totally antithetical positions through supposedly similar methodology. 

This definitely takes a lot of time, trust me. But there are so so many instances of people fitting one study or one anecdote to a specific narrative that it can be practically irresponsible to trust just the first source you see for modern issues (This holds especially for politicized issues like Green energy…again, see that Chicago Tribune article from before). 

[From all the research I’ve done, I’ve reached my own conclusions about this specific question—if you want to read it, scroll to the bottom of this post.]




This also makes me think about politics. I consider myself politically literate even though there is so much I don’t know and can never hope to know. In fact, I (like many others) am politically literate in the same way tenth graders can read—I can digest information, but I’m not going to be able to make analyses and draw conclusions the way someone who’s studied this their whole life could. Now there are some things in which I fundamentally believe because I think they are just: people should have equal rights, people shouldn’t have to go hungry, etc. And then there are things in which I believe not because I know, but only because I take the word of people who know more than me: how our involvement in the Middle East will affect our/their future, whether trickle down economics works or not, etc. 

I’ve increasingly been thinking that it’s impossible to definitively know the answers to that second group of questions. There are literally hundreds of factors simultaneously influencing these situations, and to claim there is just one cause or effect is totally narrow-minded. And then there are people who will say what they believe, even when that belief is unjustified or unsubstantiated, simply because it feels right or makes sense. (Full disclosure, I, and probably all of you, have done this before and will continue to.)

You have to really go deep when you want to know if something is genuinely true. It’s really fun to do that, and so rewarding when you arrive at something true and concrete! But it’s possible that not everything has a concrete answer. So what should we do when we encounter those problems? Well…I’m not sure. I don’t think the answer is giving up, but I sure don’t know what it is. 




~~~My own conclusions about electric vehicles and their “cleanliness”~~~

The general consensus seems to be that if the electricity needed to charge an EV (electric vehicle) is produced with clean technology (little-to-0 C02 emissions) like solar, wind, or nuclear, then the EV is better. But if it’s produced with electricity generated by the burning of coal, then it’s probably dirtier. 

My own research has lead me to believe that even in the states with the highest percentages of electricity generation spurred by coal-burning, EVs are no dirtier than gasoline-powered cars, and may even be cleaner. If you’re interested in how I reached that conclusion, contact me!

P.S. My research is still in progress, so my opinion may shift. 

EDIT: Here are my fully-researched findings: http://imgur.com/qCN7W6w